My Frustrations with Google and Adobe...

Yet again, I had to deal with another email about Adobe's announcement that millions of swf files would start showing up in search results. The misconception on Adobe's part is that by providing the ability to Google and other search engines to search within a Flash file that magically swf content will show up in search results. I am sorry, but it won't do anything for search results until Google and other search providers start indexing JavaScript or at least allow the JavaScript in SwfObject.

While what Adobe is doing is great, it isn't going to matter at all in the end. Google on it's own blog says:

"So if your web page loads a Flash file via JavaScript, Google may not be aware of that Flash file, in which case it will not be indexed."

What does this mean? This means that 99% of all websites will never show up in Google. If a site isn't using JS to embed flash content, then the site isn't being built properly. So in essence swf files will be indexed, but it will be the junk swf apps of the net.

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
Samiq's Gravatar Hear ya on it... I just wrote on the similar basis, there is
a lot to be done before we can call this a success and
start seeing results... changes have to come and people
will have to attend to them.

ping back from samiqbits

[... and when I thought I was the only one with this on me head, I found this posts laying around...]


# Posted By Samiq | 7/3/08 6:06 PM
Chris H's Gravatar you should be using the new version of swfobject, which embeds flash/flex content in a standards compliant manner. since the click to activate mechanism has been disabled in IE for months, there's no reason not to use it
# Posted By Chris H | 7/4/08 1:07 AM
Ahmet's Gravatar Totally agree, this announce is the worst I heard from a while from Adobe. It is so much marketing and so little developer friendly...


# Posted By Ahmet | 7/4/08 5:04 AM
Mark's Gravatar "99% of all websites"?

Do you mean 99% of all websites that use Flash?



58.165.87.197
# Posted By Mark | 7/13/08 11:18 PM




Google
 






The Doctor Who Fan Store  |   The Action Figure Superstore  |   The Comic Book Store  |   United States Army store  |   The Cutlery Store  |   The Craftsman Store  |   The 9/11 Store  |   The Aliens Store  |   The Locomotive Store  |   The Board Game Store  |   The Chevrolet Store  |   The Scrapbooking Store  |   The Battlestar Galactica Store  |   The General Store  |   The Warp Store  |   The Marvel Comics Store  |   Dominos and More Dominos  |   Baby Boomer Books  |   Card Games  |   Bob the Builder Store  |   Intel Core Duo Store  |   The DVD Location  |   The MP3 Store  |   Rebel Alliance  |   Lets Play Pool  |   Dumbledore's Army  |   All Saints Day - halloween  |   Fall is the season  |   The Memory Stick Store  |   Sunglasses and more  |   Harding University  |   Decorating Central  |   The allsaints Store  |   Cook Shop  |   The Georgia Shop  |   Justice League  |   LAFD  |   LAPD  |   New York State  |   NYC  |   FDNY  |   NYPD  |   The Republic of Texas Store  |   The Doctor  |   USSR  |   Allies  |   The Art House  |   The City of Atlanta  |   Axis  |   The Dark Horse Store  |   The City of Houston  |   Montey Python Store  |   iPod Store  |   The City of Providence  |   Science Fiction  |   The Sigma Store  |   The Sony Style Store  |   Tesla  |   Wal-Mart  |   Battlestar Galactica  |   Superman  |   Cylon  |   Deep Space Nine  |   Online Advertising  |   Jenga  |   Lucasfilm  |   Milton Bradley  |   Monopoly  |   Parker Brothers  |   The Scrabble Shop  |   Snowspeeder  |   Spidey  |   Spock  |   Trivial Pursuit  |   Wizards  |   Wizards of the Coast Store  |